L4M3 Questions and Answers

Qualitative KPIs are based on pure opinions about how well or otherwise the goods are performingor the service is being delivered. Most often, these will be linked to, or convertedinto, a numerical measure. However, such satisfaction surveys often also include free fields for respondents to explain why they feel the way they do, and what they might have liked to have been different.

On the other hand, quantitative KPIs are based on numerical measure with either definite number (e.g., actual number of orders incomplete or otherwise inaccurate during the time period) or as a percentage (e.g. number of inaccurate orders as a percentage of the total number of orders).

Openness and co-operation means that supplier is open and co-operative in its relationship with purchaser, e.g., in terms of joint problem solving. This KPI is qualitative since it is measured by individual judgement.

Responsiveness of supplier means the supplier responds rapidly to requests for information and support without having to be chased. It is measured by the number of times requests chased as a percentage of number of requests. It is a quantitative KPI.

Customer satisfactory ratings means the level of customer's satisfaction. This KPI is measured by periodic survey and it is a qualitative KPI.

Cost management is another quantitative KPI. It can be measured by comparing between the actual costs and the contractual costs.

OTIF (one-time in-full) deliveries is a quantitative KPI. It can be measured by counting the inaccurate deliveries in the period or inaccurate deliveries as a percentage of total number of deliveries for period.

Advantages and Disadvantages of using model form contracts.

Model form contracts save a lot of time and money. They are written by industry experts and the buyers and suppliers both understand what is included in the contract.

They are mainly used in Construction and term maintenance contacts. Typical ones are JCT and NEC.

Without the use of model form contracts the buyer and supplier will take a long time to write the terms, negotiate and finalise the contract.

This is time and money wasted.

However, model form contracts require buyers and suppliers to have training so you understand them.

Finally, if you are a buyer in a powerful position you cannot exploit that with a model form contract as these are written for mutual benefit.

Request for quotation has valuable function when its use is properly controlled. It works the best under framework agreements where the contract terms are already fixed.

FIDIC is the International Federation of Consulting Engineers (or Fédération Internationale des Ingénieurs Conseils in French). FIDIC has produced many publications, including the model form contracts, best practice guidances, research on sustainability, integrity and risk management. FIDIC model form contracts have been developed by this organisation since 1999, now they consist of several different books which are marked by colours. Thus, FIDIC model contracts also have the nickname "Rainbow suite of contracts". Basically, the "Rainbow Suite" include the following books:

* Yellow book: Plant and Design-Build Contract (2 editions: 1999 and 2017)

* Silver book: EPC/Turnkey Contract (2 editions: 1999 and 2017)

* Red book: Construction Contracts (2 editions: 1999 and 2017)

* Emerald book: Conditions of Contract for Underground Works (1st Ed 2019)

* Blue-Green book: Dredgers Contract (2 editions: 2006 and 2016)

* Gold book: Design, Build and Operate Contract Guide

* Pink book: Construction Contract Multilateral Development Bank Harmonised Ed (2 editions: 2005 and 2010)

This type of model contract is commonly used around the world because its author, International Federation of Consulting Engineers, collaborates closely with development banks such as World Bank, Africa Development Bank, Asia Development Bank, etc. Every construction project that is financed by these institutions must adopt the FIDIC contracts.

The Joint Contracts Tribunal, also known as the JCT, produces standard forms of contract for construction, guidance notes and other standard documentation for use in the constructionindustry in the United Kingdom. From its establishment in 1931, JCT has expanded the number of contributing organisations.

ITC (International Trade Centre) produces contracts specifically designed for small companies doing international business, covering the sale of goods, distribution, services and joint ventures. Many small companies are now engaged in international trade, but don’t have access to the necessary contract forms to protect themselves. ITC and leading legal experts developed eight generic contract templates that incorporate internationally recognized standards and laws for most small business situations.

CIPS has several model forms of contract designed specifically for IT buying and servicing.

There are 3 types of KPI measure:

- Binary KPIs

- Quantitative KPIs (or numerical)

- Qualitative KPIs

User satisfaction is subjective, therefore, using qualitative assessment is the best answer.

Incentivised pricing is designed to motivate suppliers to meet or exceed performance targets by providing financial or other incentives. In urgent projects, such as constructing a hospital ward during a pandemic, incentivised pricing encourages suppliers to accelerate delivery without compromising on quality. This supports the buyer’s need for speed and reliability.

Indexation and price adjustment clauses are appropriate when future costs are uncertain or likely to change, such as regulatory-driven wage increases (B) or fluctuating material costs (E). These clauses allow adjustments based on objective indices while preserving the integrity of the contract.

KPIs that involve actual counts or quantifiable incidents are considered quantitative and use numerical data. "Late deliveries" and "accidents or near misses" are measured in numbers, making them suitable for numerical performance tracking. The other options relate more to qualitative analysis or subjective feedback.

Effective KPIs should be measurable, relevant, and tied to performance. "Complaints resolved within two days" and "Delivery of goods on time and in full" are standard KPIs as they reflect quality and timeliness of service—both key to contract success. The "total number of services" and general reductions do not directly reflect performance outcomes.

Consideration only appears in common law countries. Below are some examples of what is and what is not consideration:

- Past consideration is something that has already been done or given. This cannot act as consideration

- Implied consideration: if the detail of a promise to pay is expressed after the provision of goods or services, but there is an implication that such promise would be forthcoming, this may (depending on the facts) be valid consideration.

- A promise given to a third party: this is not normally consideration, and is based on a concept known as privity of contract. Anyone who is not a party to the contract, even if they are beneficiary of it, cannot sue if the terms of the contract are breached.

- A promise to perform over and above an existing obligation: This is always consideration

- Strict liability, sometimes called absolute liability, is the legal responsibility for damages, or injury, even if the person found strictly liable was not at fault or negligent. Strict liability has been applied to certain activities in tort, such as holding an employer absolutely liable for the torts of her employees, but today it is most commonly associated with defectively manufactured products. In addition, for reasons of public policy, certain activities may be conducted only if the person conducting them is willing to insure others against the harm that results from the risks the activities create.

- Current liabilities are a company's short-term financial obligations that are due within one year or within a normal operating cycle.

- Non-current liabilities, also called long-term liabilities or long-term debts, are long-term financial obligations listed on a company’s balance sheet

- Contingent liability is a potential liability that may occur, depending on the outcome of an uncertain future event.

A service-level agreement (SLA) defines the level of service you expect from a vendor, laying out the metrics by which service is measured, as well as remedies or penalties should agreed-on service levels not be achieved.

According to CIPS L4M3 study guide, SLA should cover the following:

- KPIs

- How the measurements convert into scores

- Any other service level standards

- Minimum acceptable standards or scores in each case

- Range of scores both above and below the minimum acceptable

- Any mitigating factors which might apply in the event of poor performance

- Any time period permitted in which to remedy a situation of poor performance

- Remedies available

- Dispute settlement

- How to deal with inconsistencies or conflicts between KPIs and any other documents.

In IT service (such as in the scenario), the SLA often covers:

- Uptime

- Call metrics

- Customer satisfaction

- Turn around time

- Quality

- Mean time to recovery

- Mean time between failure

- Backlog

- Business results

You can read the details of above indicators here.

Audit trail is a chronological record the sequence of events connected to a given transaction, such as a purchase of raw materials, payroll disbursements, or a detailed financial statement. The record includes all the source documents connected to the transaction, providing context and clarity in the event a review is required. The more comprehensive the documentation, the more effective the audit trail is when used to create financial reports, verify information, and ensure compliance while eliminating fraud.

In the scenario, the procurement team gets the quotation from phone calls and emails which have weak audit trails and lack of transparency. One solution may be increasing the use of e-procurement system.

In the absence of a clearly defined delivery date, contract law defaults to performance within a “reasonable time.” Given that no firm delivery date was agreed upon and the goods were delivered in a timeframe consistent with known production and delivery times, the supplier is not in breach.

In the 'battle of the forms', generally who shot the last will win. This is not applied to this case. Initial RFQ is an invitation to treat, then the quotation forms an offer. Transformers & Rectifiers Ltd edits terms and conditions then sends back to supplier, this act terminates Needs's offer and makes a new offer. Delivery of goods can be deemed as acceptance from Needs Ltd. The contract is formed with its details in the edited terms and conditions.

BS 7373-1:2001 Product specifications. Guide to preparation gives guidance on layout, preparation and management. The subject has been treated in a generic way and guidance can be used in the preparation of all types.

BS 5864:2019 is the standard for installation and maintenance of gas-fired ducted air heaters of rated heat input not exceeding 70 kW net (2nd and 3rd family gases). Specification

BS 5975:2019 is the standard for code of practice for temporary works procedures and the permissible stress design of falsework.

BS EN 60601-1-11:2015 is the standard for medical electrical equipment. General requirements for basic safety and essential performance. Collateral Standard: Requirements for medical electrical equipment and medical electrical systems used in the home healthcare environment.

This question is intended to let students know about how contractual clauses regarding ethical issues is constructed. The exam paper may not ask about this.

"Each Party hereby undertakes that, at the date of the entering into force of the Contract, itself, its directors, officers or employees have not offered, promised, given, authorized, solicited or accepted any undue pecuniary or other advantage of any kind in any way connected with the Contract and that it has taken reasonable measures to prevent subcontractors, agents or any other third parties, subject to its control or determining influence, from doing so.": This is a clause addressing fraud, bribery and corruption. It is created to prevent any undue act by contracting parties. You may find other anti-corruption clause samples in this document.

"Nothing in this Agreement shall prevent a Party from utilizing the services of any subcontractor as it deems appropriate to perform its obligations under this Agreement; provided, however, that each Party shall require its subcontractors to comply with all applicable terms and conditions of this Agreement in providing such services and each Party shall remain primarily liable to the other Party for the performance of such subcontractor.": This clause is used to control the subcontracting and subcontractors.

"Customer will be responsible for and shall ensure that while Service Provider employees, agents or contractors are on Customer’s premises, all proper and legal health and safety precautions arein place and fully operational to protect such persons.": This clause is used to ensure health and safety standards.

"The Company has undertaken commercially reasonable efforts to eliminate Conflict Minerals from each Company Product and any products currently proposed to be manufactured by the Company or on its behalf in the future. “Conflict Minerals” means columbite-tantalite (coltan), cassiterite, gold, wolframite, or their derivatives, which originate in the Democratic Republic of the Congo or other country the exploitation and trade of which is determined by the United States to be financing conflict in the Democratic Republic of the Congo or other country.": This is a clause addressing conflict minerals.

In a 'battle of the forms', both buyer and supplier exchange documents with conflicting terms. The general rule is that the terms of the last document exchanged before performance (e.g., delivery or payment) that is not objected to will govern the contract. An order acknowledgement from the supplier with its own terms, followed by acceptance (e.g., payment), usually constitutes the final word.

Early market engagement is encouraged in procurement best practices. It helps procurement teams understand new technologies, identify capable suppliers, and inform the development of effective specifications and contract terms. However, it must be non-binding and conducted fairly to ensure no supplier gains an unfair advantage.

Hank’s pre-contractual assurances may amount to misrepresentation. Fraudulent misrepresentation is a strong possibility since Hank had carried out no investigations into the viability of the project timescales. This could amount to recklessness in using information without taking any steps to see if it is true or not.

The scenario above was constructed based on the case BSkyB v EDS, a famous case in IT sector.

LO 1, AC 1.2

This urgent needs occasionally occur due to a sudden change in circumstances. The process for selecting a replacement supplier must still be controlled. If there is a reason for normal processes to be waived, this must be fully documented and approved at a high level.

Contracting on the supplier’s terms can pose risks for the buyer. Common disadvantages include retention of title clauses (C), where the supplier retains ownership of goods until full payment is made. Also, suppliers may include clauses allowing them to raise prices without notification (E). These terms shift risk to the buyer and reduce predictability and control.

Information Assurance (IA) is the practice of managing information-related risks and the steps involved to protect information systems such as computer and network systems. The IA transformation is a partnership that stretches across the Department of Defense (DoD), Office of National Intelligence, Committee on National Security Systems, National Institute of Science and Technology (NIST), and the Office of Management and Budget.

The US Government's definition of information assurance is:

“measures that protect and defend information and information systems by ensuring their availability, integrity, authentication, confidentiality, and non-repudiation. These measures include providing for restoration of information systems by incorporating protection, detection, and reaction capabilities.”

Hank’s pre-contractual assurances may amount to misrepresentation. Remedies for misrepresentation could be rescission of contract or damages. Rescission will be impossible in the following instance:

- Where the innocent party has affirmed the contract; that is, acted in a way confirming that they wish it to continue

- Where the claim has not been brought within a reasonable time (this is a point of general law)

- Where restitution (returning to the pre-contractual position) is impossible (e.g. because the goods have been consumed or have deteriorated)

- Where there has been intervention of innocent third-party (e.g., if the goods have been sold on)

In this case, the subject of contract is designing, building and managing the new CRM system which is impossible to be restituted. Therefore, the contract cannot be rescinded.

Creating a detailed specification and publicly advertising the requirement are key preparatory steps in issuing an ITT (Invitation to Tender). These ensure that suppliers understand the requirement and have the opportunity to respond, promoting transparency and competition.

An implied term is a term which the courts imply into a contract because it has not been expressly included by the parties. This may be because the parties did not consider it, did not think that any problem would arise in relation to it or simply omitted to include it.

The courts are very reluctant to imply terms into contracts and will only do so in the following circumstances:

- terms implied under statute

- terms implied under common law

- terms implied because of custom or usage

- terms implied due to previous dealings

- terms implied ‘in fact’ or to reflect the parties’ intentions

A price adjustment clause, also known as a price variation or indexation clause, provides a structured method for managing potential changes in price over the contract's duration. This clause ensures that any price increase must be based on predefined and agreed-upon criteria, such as inflation rates or cost indices. This prevents arbitrary or unexpected price increases from the supplier.

Specifying that suppliers hold certification to standards like ISO 14001 offers assurance that they adhere to recognised environmental management practices, promoting consistency and reliability. Such standards are internationally recognised, facilitating understanding among both local and global bidders. However, certification does not guarantee the exclusion of all polluting suppliers, nor does it eliminate the need for internal environmental training within the purchasing organisation.

'Consensus ad idem' is a Latin term meaning “meeting of the minds.” It refers to both parties having the same understanding and intention regarding the contract’s terms. This mutual agreement is essential for forming a valid and enforceable contract.

IMechE/IET: Institution of Mechanical Engineers/Institution of Engineering and Technology - two separate institutes that issue jointly agreed model forms covering the design, supply and installation of electrical, electronic and mechanical plant including special conditions for the ancillary development of software. Car lifts are mechanical products, so IMechE/IET is the most suitable model contract for this type of product.

FIDIC is a French language acronym for Fédération Internationale Des Ingénieurs-Conseils, which means the international federation of consulting engineers. It was started in 1913 by the trio of France, Belgium and Switzerland. The United Kingdom joined the Federation in 1949. FIDIC is headquartered in Switzerland and now boasts of membership from over 60 different countries. FIDIC published its first contract, titled The Form of contract for works of Civil Engineering construction, in 1957. As the title indicated, this first contract was aimed at the Civil Engineering sector and it soon became known for the colour of its cover, and thus, The Red Book. It has become the tradition that FIDIC contracts are known in popular parlance by the colour of their cover. This first contract by FIDIC was undertaken jointly with the International federation of Building and Public works. FIDIC’s concerted effort at achieving broad consultation and acceptance of its contract forms has seen subsequent editions of its contracts being ratified by the International Federation of Asian and Western Pacific Contractors Association, Associated General Contractors of America and the Inter-American Federation of the Construction Industry, Multilateral Development Banks among others. Because of the broad support it enjoys, FIDIC contracts are the foremost contracts in international construction.

The Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply (CIPS) has some model contracts for IT functions including: supply and installation of computer equipment, support and maintenance of bespoke software, servicing of computer equipment,...

The International Trade Centre (ITC) produces contracts specifically designed for small companies doing international business, covering the sale of goods, distribution, services and joint ventures.

A cost reimbursable contract (sometimes called a cost plus contract) is one in which the contractor is reimbursed the actual costs they incur in carrying out the works, plus an additional fee. Option Eof the NEC3 Engineering and Construction Contract (ECC) is an example of a cost reimbursable contract.

Generally, under the Sale of Goods Acts (in UK, Singapore, Australia,...) or Commercial Codes (in France, Germany, Vietnam,...), the sale contracts have the following implied terms:

- the seller has the right to sell the goods. This is also a condition of the contract

- the goods are free from undisclosed security interests

- the goods supplied under the contract will be reasonably fit for any purpose which the buyer made known to the seller

- sales of unseen goods will be of merchantable quality, and match their description and conformwith a sample.

- Passing of risk

- Passing of possession and title

The organisation should have an overarching strategies or policies which sets out the social and environmental objectives to be pursued via procurement and the supply chain generally. Some of these will be about the specification, but that must be tied in other aspects of the sourcing strategy. These objectives, policies and strategies can be found in corporate social responsibility policy.

A framework agreement is an agreement with one or more suppliers/providers which sets out terms and conditions under which individual contracts (call-offs) can be made throughout the term of the agreement.

A framework agreement itself is not a contract, but the call-offs made from it are.

Framework arrangements create a streamlined and flexible process for procuring goods, works or services

Where a framework for the same goods, works or services is awarded to several suppliers, there are three possible options for awarding call-off contracts: direct award (or direct call-off), mini-competition or a combination of both.

Option 1 – Apply the terms of the framework agreement (direct award).

Where your requirements match the terms and/or specification of the framework agreement (in the event of any query, you should clarify the situation with the organisation that established the framework), a particular call-off should be awarded without re-opening competition. The call-off should be awarded to the provider who is identified as the most economically advantageous tender based on the award criteria used at the time that the framework was established (i.e. the supplier ranked no. 1). Randomly selecting a supplier off a framework is not permitted.

Option 2 – Hold a mini-competition between capable suppliers.

If your requirements do not match the terms and/or the specification of the framework, you should conduct a mini-competition exercise. Whilst it is not permitted to substantially change the basic terms or specification of the framework, in running a mini-competition it is possible to supplement or refine the basic terms of the framework prior to making a call-off. Examples of such terms are:

- The particular goods/services/works required;

- Particular delivery timescales;

- Particular invoicing arrangements and payment profiles;

- Associated services such as installation, maintenance and training;

- Quantity;

- Functional specification.

Under no circumstances should brand names or brand-specific descriptions of goods be used e.g. BIC Biro Pen, Hewlett-Packard Printer, Dell computer. Descriptions should give reference to the characteristics and outputs of the product or service. Where no other description is possible, any reference should be qualified by adding the words ‘or equivalent’.

When a mini-competition exercise is held, all suppliers appointed to the framework that are capableof meeting the requirement must be invited to submit a tender. (This might just relate to suppliers within a particular ‘lot’). You must not limit the mini-competition exercise to selected providers. A time limit for submitting the tender must be set and advised to competing suppliers. This time limit must be reasonable, taking account of the complexity of the requirement.

The call-off must be awarded on the basis of the framework award criteria and new criteria cannot be added, although, where permitted, the weightings may be varied to take account of a particular requirement. However, in adjusting the weightings, care must be taken to ensure that any such changes do not have an adverse effect on competition.

Option 3 - Combination of direct award and mini-competition

To use a combination approach, the procurement documents must state that this route may be used. The procurement documents will also specify which terms may be subject to the re-opening of competition.

One-off contract is the type of contract that relates to a single purchase. One-off contracts can be used for goods, services or works. One-off contract can be simple (such as buying a small number of office stationeries) or complex (such as a construction project or buying an aircraft).

A one-off contract lasts “until completion of the obligations of the parties”. The performance is unlikely to be improved during contract performance since the duration is relatively shorter than framework agreement or call-off contract.

Ad-hoc purchase is an item bought for a single and non-recurring use or purpose. Ad-hoc purchase is a type of one-off contract.

The market approach is a method of determining the value of an asset based on the selling price of similar assets.

A fixed-price strategy means you set a price and keep it constant for an extended period of time.

Cost-plus pricing is also known as markup pricing. It's a pricing method where a fixed percentage is added on top of the cost to produce

A price index (PI) is a measure of how prices change over a period of time, or in other words, it is a way to measure inflation. There are multiple methods on how to calculate inflation (or deflation).

Call-off or blanket orders are common procurement tools used to streamline the acquisition of routine, low-value items. This reduces the administrative workload and simplifies the process, allowing multiple deliveries under a single contract, thereby increasing efficiency and control.

The formation of the contract is where the contractual journey begins; if no contract is formed, neither of the parties can be under any obligations. Therefore, it is very important to have an understanding of each part of a contract’s formation.

In order for a legally binding agreement to be formed, there are four basic requirements to be met:

2.1 Offer

2.2 Acceptance

2.3 Certainty & Intention to Create Legal Relations

2.4 Consideration & Promissory Estoppel

SFO issued an RFQ with defined terms and condition and detailed specification. This RFQ can be considered as an invitation to treat. Vogon's quotation is an answer to the purchaser's RFQ and is an offer to SFO. The contract come to life at the time Vogon received the notification from SFO senior management.

The strike may be a force majeur event, depending on the contract particular clauses and jurisdiction. In common law countries, force majeur is applicable as an exclusion of liability only if the contract allows it. In many civil law countries, force majeur is an implied term. But in every jurisdiction, force majeur is only a reason for excluding liability for non-performance of a contract. In other words, the non-performance party is not liable for any breach if force majeur event occurs but the event does not exclude the breach.

LO 1, AC 1.2

A Retention of Title clause allows the seller to retain ownership of goods until full payment is received. If included in a contract, this clause would have enabled ACC to claim ownership of the number plates and potentially recover them from Elite Motors Ltd, even in administration. It protects suppliers against buyer insolvency.

A contract for window cleaning during the next three months is a short-term service contract in which changes of input costs (labour, tools,...) are very unlikely to happen.

Fixed pricing arrangement is useful for small to medium scope project, with short timelines, where what is delivered can be adequately specified and the likelihood of changes to the specification, scope and input costs is limited.

The procurement team has drafted basic requirements in the specification. They will need to develop it further and more specific. Developing market dialogue with supplier is a good solution. There are number of approaches which can be taken to engage with suppliers:

- General meetings: buyer meets supplier at a networking event (such as trade show) or social media. These discussions are unlikely to deliver very specific information.

- One-to-one meetings: This will be most likely to deliver direct input into specification development and supplier-specific product development information.

- Group visits

- Meet-the-buyer events

- Formal negotiations or competitive

The answer for this QUESTION should be One-to-one meeting.

Markup is the percentage between the profit and costs. The cost is $350, markup is 11%. So final price is: 350 + 350x0.11 = 388.5

Number of on-time deliveries can be quantified, then numerical measures can be applied.

Frequency of on-time deliveries is measured as on-time deliveries as a percentage of total no. of deliveries for period.

LO 2, AC 2.2

Retention money is the payment for a service or product that is withheld pending the completion of some specified condition. For example, buyer may withhold the amount due until the supplier replace all defective goods.

Pay-less notice is the notice under a contract which states that the invoice will only be partially paid because of some issues such as supplier has to pay the damages.

Remedies for late payment are remedies that supplier may seek when a buyer pay it later than the stated payment terms. Normally, the buyer will be charged an interest rate.

The best way to manage conflicts of interest is through transparency and fairness. Including multiple suppliers in the market engagement process ensures no single supplier, including the one with a perceived connection, gains an advantage. This protects the integrity of the procurement process.

Procurement teams use key performance indicators (KPIs) to ensure vendors comply with (and hopefully exceed) the obligations outlined in a contract. They help us better understandsuppliers’ performance, measure their output over a long period of time, and identify areas where improvement is needed.

Put simply, it’s good business sense to make sure you’re actually getting what you’ve paid for. This might be as straightforward as confirming a product or service is delivered on time, which means the KPIs you need to use will be minimal and basic.

A non-disclosure agreement is used to protect confidential information shared during discussions or collaborations. It ensures that sensitive data is not disclosed to unauthorized parties and maintains trust between contractual parties during tendering or negotiation.

Standards are incorporated into specifications by simply cross-refering to the relevant standard by its number and date of publication. It is important to include the date of publication. All standardsare reviewed from time to time and their content changes. The absence of the publication date will lead to disrupts over which version of the standard actually applies to the contract.

A false statement that induces a party to enter a contract constitutes misrepresentation. This provides the misled party with remedies that may include rescission (cancellation of the contract) and, depending on the type of misrepresentation (fraudulent, negligent), possibly damages as well.

Model form contracts streamline procurement processes by providing pre-agreed and widely understood terms, which reduce the time and legal costs of contract drafting. These are especially useful in complex industries and promote consistency and fairness.

In order to form a contract to come into being, there are five conditions:

- Offer

- Acceptance

- Consideration

- Intention to be legally bound

- Capacity to contract